Wednesday, February 28, 2024

Join Paper Mill Playhouse in the Carriage House for these March events!



Paper Mill Playhouse, Join us at the Carriage House. Carriage House Presents. From murder mystery dinner show to musical theater trivia nights, join us for a host of deliciously entertaining events.


More than a magic show

Matthew Swanson: Sink With Me

MARCH 1 & 2

All seating begins at 6:15 PM.

Embark on an intimate journey through our enchanting realm of theater and make-believe. This brand-new show is a fully interactive piece of revelatory theatre that delves into the profound magic of tarot, palm readings, cartomancy, and the mesmerizing world of real magic.

We invite you to embrace the extraordinary, where every performance is a heartfelt exploration and no two shows are ever the same. Sink with Me is more than just a magic show. It's a genuine connection shared amongst a group of strangers through the power of theater and the suspension of disbelief—a celebration of the magic within us all.

Sink With Me is recommended for adults.

$39 reservation cost per person paid at the time of order

$60 dinner cost per person* paid at the end of the event

*Beverages, tax, and gratuity are not included in the prix fixe total.





Murder Mystery Dinner

Murder on the Titanic

MARCH 8, 9, 15, 16 & 23

Seating begins at 6:00 PM. Performance begins at 7:00 PM and ends by 9:30 PM.

Set sail with Without a Cue Productions aboard the RMS Titanic. Enjoy the food, waltz to the music, but stay alert! Rumor has it that one of the passengers is harboring a dark secret and may go as far as murder to keep the truth from being known. Can you solve this century-old mystery?

$40 ticket charge per guest paid at the time of order

$58 three-course prix fixe meal per person* paid in person on the night of the event

*Beverages, tax, and gratuity are not included in the prix-fixe total.





Trivia Night

Broadway & Entertainment


Seating begins at 6:00 PM. Trivia begins at 7:00 PM and ends at 9:00 PM.

Best Men Trivia are back with another evening of Pop Culture: Broadway & Entertainment Trivia. Get your teams of two, three, or four people and sign up! Learn more about our trivia hosts at

Prizes include a $50 gift certificate to the Carriage House and Paper Mill swag.
Participants will also be entered to win a pair of tickets to your choice of one of the final two mainstage productions of Paper Mill's 2023–2024 season: Gun & Powder, or Beautiful: The Carole King Musical!

Free admission and parking.

Reservations highly suggested. Single participants may be seated at the bar based on table availability.

Two drink or food item minimum per person from a special Trivia Menu.





Save the dates

Restaurant Week

MARCH 17–23

(Closed Monday and Tuesday)

Carriage House Presents will participate in Restaurant Week of Millburn-Short Hills, including themed murder mystery dinners, live music, a wines-of-France dinner, trivia, and karaoke with special Restaurant Week culinary offerings. More information coming soon!