CCP was honored in the following categories:
- OUTSTANDING LIGHTING DESIGN FOR A PLAY: Sean Hennessy, The Pillowman
- OUTSTANDING COSTUME DESIGN FOR A PLAY: Fran Harrison, The Graduate
- OUTSTANDING COSTUME DESIGN FOR A MUSICAL: Fran Harrison, OLIVER!
- OUTSTANDING DIRECTION OF A PLAY: Bob Pridham, The Graduate
- OUTSTANDING PRODUCTION OF A PLAY: Chris Furlong, Producer / Bob Pridham Director, The Graduate
- OUTSTANDING LEAD ACTOR IN A PLAY: Matthew J. Cronin, The Graduate; Rick Holloway, The Pillowman
- OUTSTANDING LEAD ACTRESS IN A PLAY: Julie Waldman-Stiel, The Graduate
- OUTSTANDING LEAD ACTRESS IN A MUSICAL: Christina Ryan, OLIVER!
- OUTSTANDING SUPPORTING ACTOR IN A PLAY: Peter Horn, The Pillowman; Michael King, The Pillowman
- OUTSTANDING SUPPORTING ACTRESS IN A PLAY: Elizabeth Royce, The Graduate
- OUTSTANDING FEATURED ACTOR IN A PLAY: Elliot T. Schulz, The Graduate
- OUTSTANDING FEATURED ACTRESS IN A PLAY: Natalia Blanco, The Graduate
- OUTSTANDING YOUTH ACTRESS IN A PLAY: Brielle Raddi, The Pillowman
- OUTSTANDING PRODUCTION OF AN ORIGINAL PLAY: Bob Denmark, Producer/Arnold Buchiane, Director/ Cynthia Wiese-Manno, Director/ Joanne Lopresti Scanlon, Director/Sherrie Ahlin, Director/ Mark C. Phelan, Director/ Don Howes, Director/ Constantine Kitsopoulos, Musical Director, Jersey Voices 2009
NJACT bestows Perry Awards in 33 performance and technical categories. Candidates with the top seven scores in each category are considered nominees. The candidate with the highest score in each category receives the Perry Award. There are also four Special Perry Awards available each year at the discretion of the NJACT Board of Directors. They are the Community Theater of the Year Award, the Lifetime Achievement Award, the David P. McMenemie Award, and the Perry Award for Outstanding Stage Management.